BESTWIRE: Consumer Group Says Proposed California Ballot Question Unfair
By Sean P. Carr, BESTWIRE
LOS ANGELES, CA — A ballot initiative sponsored by Mercury General Corp. could lead to massive surcharges on motorists who had even a brief lapse in insurance coverage, no matter the reason, a consumer advocacy group claims.
If approved by California voters, the initiative would invalidate a component of the state’s Proposition 103 that barred insurance companies from charging customers more for not having had automobile insurance coverage in the past, said Harvey Rosenfield, founder of Consumer Watchdog and the author of Proposition 103. It will allow insurance companies to raise premiums on those with a coverage lapse of 90 days or more over the past five years, he said. The impact would be disproportionately felt by those who did not need insurance for certain periods — including those without cars for a time, military personnel, students and the temporarily unemployed — plus anyone whose coverage was canceled for even a single late payment, Rosenfield said.
In states where such charges are allowed, a lapse in insurance coverage can result in significantly higher premiums. Rosenfield pointed to a video demonstration that showed quote differentials of 67% in Texas and 227% in Florida between identical consumers who had previous coverage and those who did not.
“Mercury General wants to legalize a vicious penalty,” he said.
Mercury General is the funder behind Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates. According to CalFAIR, the proposition would allow insurance companies to lower premiums for drivers who “have continuously maintained auto insurance coverage,” even if they switch to a different insurer. Those with lapses in payments may be disqualified from such discounts. Under current law, an insurer may offer discounts to policyholders who maintain “continuous” coverage only with their company. The proposition would not change the provisions in current law that require insurers to base their rates primarily on driving safety record, miles driven annually and driving experience (BestWire, Sept. 10, 2009).
CalFAIR spokeswoman Kathy Fairbanks disputed Rosenfield’s analysis.
“Contrary to what opponents have said about the measure, the fact is that the Continuous Coverage Auto Insurance Discount Act will encourage competition and choice in the auto insurance marketplace. It will save consumers money on their auto policies, and it will reward the more than 80% of responsible California drivers who maintain auto insurance as required by law,” she said in a statement. “Today, those drivers are penalized. Current law restricts drivers from going to other insurers to shop for lower prices because they can’t take the continuous coverage discount with them.”
Last month, CalFAIR said it turned in more than 720,000 signatures to county registrars. Under California law, 433,971 valid signatures must be verified to place the measure on the June or November ballots. Once the signatures are counted by the counties, the Secretary of State’s office will rule on the validity (BestWire, Dec. 15, 2009).
Mercury Insurance Co. (NYSE: MCY), a member of Mercury General Group, currently has a Best’s Financial Strength Rating of A+ (Superior).
The top five writers of private passenger auto insurance in California in 2008, according to BestLink, were: State Farm Group, with a 12.9% market share; Farmers Insurance Group, 11.0%; Mercury General Group, 9.4%; Auto Club Enterprises Insurance Group, 9.0%; and Allstate Insurance Group, 8.4%.
Mercury General stock was trading at $38.31 a share the afternoon of Jan. 20, down 1.26% from the previous close.
Contact the author Sean P. Carr, Washington Correspondent, at: [email protected]