Did Mercury pay for a witness to provide false testimony?

fold

January 12th, 2010 Posted by editor

Bookmark and Share

by Naomi Seligman

Mercury Insurance executives have long operated the company using questionable and deceptive tactics. 

Now, an Illinois accident victim, Steven Kirk, is asking for sanctions from Mercury Insurance for allegedly paying a witness to provide false testimony about his accident.

In the motion, Kirk claims the insurance company persuaded defense witness Helen Brockman to lie about witnessing the 2006 motorcycle crash.

Brockman admitted to having mental illness and learning disabilities during her testimony in the case. She testified that she saw Kirk from her apartment and that he was riding drunk, swerving and speeding.

Kirk admitted to drinking prior to the accident during his trial.

In rebuttal, the plaintiff put Brockman’s landlord on the stand. He produced her hand-written rental application for her Ridge Street apartment. It shows that Brockman didn’t rent the apartment until six months following the accident.

Brockman also testified that she had been recruited by investigators for the trial. In the motion, the plaintiff says those investigators were hired by Mercury.

“Ms. Brockman was spoon fed her ‘facts,’” the plaintiff’s motion reads. “Plaintiff has reason to suspect that Mercury offered bribes to people to testify at trial. Perpetration of fraud is not favored. This Court should not allow Mercury to get away with the fabrication of witnesses.”

In his closing argument, plaintiff’s attorney Chris Kolker hammered at Brockman’s testimony and urged jurors to award his client $5 million.

As soon as we know, we will post how the court rules on Kolker’s  motion.

Tags:

Comments are closed.