When Auto Insurance Customers Are The Victims

fold

May 4th, 2010

Bookmark and Share

By Shane, THE AUTO INSURANCE.COM

We’ve written quite a bit about how some otherwise honest auto insurance customers attempt to defraud their insurers – but it sometimes it works the other way as well. For example, earlier this month, we covered a case in Louisiana in which an insurance agent was pocketing customer’s premiums without writing up the policies for which they had paid (see “Insurance Fraud Continues as Recession Drags On”).

Sometimes however, it’s more insidious. Consider the case of Mercury Insurance, one of California’s largest underwriters of auto insurance policies.

Are Corporations “People”?

We discussed California’s controversial Proposition 17 a few weeks ago (”When Does a Lapse in Coverage Justify Higher Rates?”), which would allow an auto insurer to offer a “persistency discount” to a customer who switches from another auto insurer – thus forcing insurance companies to compete harder for clients. The major argument against the proposed law is that it would possibly allow auto insurers to penalize people who drop their auto coverage for a time because they don’t actually own a vehicle.

Sadly, proponents and opponents of the law have filed suits and counter-suits in civil court and have muddied the issues so badly that the average voter really doesn’t understand what’s at stake.

However, some interesting facts have come out about the legislation’s corporate sponsor, Mercury Insurance.

The Regulator’s Report

According to the California Department of Insurance (CDI), Mercury has been overcharging customers since the mid-1990s – and doing this in a variety of ways, including failure to offer discounts mandated by the state, imposing illegal “fees” and surcharges, and even outright discrimination on the basis of medical issues and even occupation.

Interestingly, Mercury has been spending millions on advertising aimed at convincing California voters to approve Proposition 17 – a law the company had a hand in writing.

The CDI report reveals that Mercury had denied coverage to drivers who are legally handicapped and is continuing to charge certain customers who are required to carry proof of coverage a surcharge equal to 15% above and beyond their premiums. The company has also been charging their customers for accidents in which they were not the responsible party and prematurely canceled policies for low income people who qualified for California’s Low Cost Automobile Insurance Plan.

Not surprisingly, JD Power, which ranks insurers in terms of customer service and consumer satisfaction, places Mercury near the bottom.

Credibility Issues

On the surface, regardless of who authored the proposed legislation, Proposition 17 would seem to be a good deal for consumers. However, controversy over “Corporate Personhood” aside (as when a corporation – such as an auto insurer – writes legislation, which is actually the job of natural, human lawmakers), at a time when people are increasingly outraged by the way business has been inserting itself into the political process, this report is very likely to destroy any credibility Mercury’s ad campaigns might have had. This makes it unlikely that Proposition 17 will pass in June.

Tags: , , , , ,

Leave a Reply